01 June 2024

Bleak Mirror (Review: 'Doctor Who' 1.5, "Dot and Bubble")

  • This will inevitably be compared with Black Mirror - in fact, RTD came up with the concept before that show was a thing.
  • It does start off a bit saccharine and silly, but I think that's part of the point.
  • The Doctor and Millie spend most of their episodes on a screen; perhaps this was another thing linked to Ncuti Gatwa's filming for Sex Education?
  • How does someone go for multiple days without urinating at all? What do they eat and drink on Finetime?
  • Very good performance by Ncuti and Millie in general; especially Fifteen's frustration at the end.
  • Lindy Pepper-Bean's general saccharinity makes the twist at the end much more dramatic, but also serves as a reminder of what we all could do in a situation like that.
  • This thing is saying an awful lot about being reliant on technology. I went to Kelvedon Hatch bunker today and one would not hold up much hope for an influencer in any nuclear exchange. Except for any survivalist ones, who might have a chance.
  • Some of the elements of this episode don't really bear close scrutiny; it's more a parable than anything else, I'd say.
  • Having the supposedly vapid pop star actually be most in tune with the situation was a good twist.
  • That's a stupid way to operate a door mechanism.
  • I'd argue that defeating the genocidal AI might be a priority, Doctor, before it tries it on anyone else.
  • The ending is downright bleak and seeing the Doctor turn away, knowing there's nothing he can do, is really quite moving.

Review

Definitely one of the darker episodes I've seen from Russell T Davies, or indeed Doctor Who for quite a long time. It starts a bit silly, but the payoff is worth it.

8/10

Edit: I managed to completely miss the bigotry displayed in this episode by the people of Finetime. Which says a lot about white privilege, I suppose.

No comments: