30 October 2023

Bottle Episode of Ham (Review: 'Star Trek' 3.9, "The Tholian Web")

  • Star Trek had two dedicated studios for its use at Desilu's studios - Stage 9 and Stage 10, now Paramount Stages 31 and 32. Stage 9 was used for the Enterprise sets, with Stage 10 used for off-ship scenes. This one used Stage 9 pretty much entirely entirely.
  • This is very clearly a budget-saving episode, albeit one with a fairly large number of extras - the most ship personnel in one scene in fact for TOS. The Defiant is clearly a redressed Enterprise bridge, the interior only seen in one scene.
  • They seem to have missed a bit explaining why the transporter went down in the first place.
  • Chekov's screaming is particularly memorable, that's for sure.
  • DeForest Kelley does very good anger.
  • Why did they not believe Uhura when she saw Kirk? Are they stupid?
  • As Memory Alpha has pointed out, this is not Starfleet's first mutiny. It's not even the first TOS mutiny.
  • The environment suits from this actually look pretty decent, although were apparently a real problem when it came to bodily functions. But "MC COY" with a space in the middle.
  • The effects on this episode got the show an Emmy nomination. That rather shows how far the VFX industry has come since 1968.
  • The Tholian ship comes in rather too slowly for something flying at half the speed of light.
  • Injecting someone through a spacesuit? That doesn't seem like it would work.
Conclusion

It's a bottle episode, sure, but sometimes those can be among the best a show does. I wouldn't say it's one of the best Star Trek episodes, but it's still pretty good.

8/10
 

No comments: